Fix web-search framing in form-language grammar provenance
Both the Ecuador form-language run and the Harbor House validation run used real web search, per Salingaros - so paper.md's "stricter, source-checked mode... as well as the original's" wording asserted a methodological contrast that didn't exist. Reframe as a shared condition, and add the more defensible caveat that even with search available, current LLM tooling likely synthesized both grammars from textual search results rather than genuine visual analysis of images. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
parent
9b8d2fc1f4
commit
002509f358
2 changed files with 26 additions and 15 deletions
|
|
@ -285,14 +285,17 @@ Scale notes for the project this grammar will serve: {SCALE_NOTES}.
|
||||||
away, the same way a pattern-language narrative generated downstream
|
away, the same way a pattern-language narrative generated downstream
|
||||||
should be checked against its selected pattern subset.
|
should be checked against its selected pattern subset.
|
||||||
- Salingaros described his original prompt as asking the LLM to "locate
|
- Salingaros described his original prompt as asking the LLM to "locate
|
||||||
open-source images of traditional buildings" and synthesize from them.
|
open-source images of traditional buildings" and synthesize from them,
|
||||||
It's unclear whether that literally happened, as opposed to the model
|
and has confirmed the session used a real web-search-enabled LLM
|
||||||
drawing on general training-data familiarity with named buildings and
|
configuration, not training-data recollection alone. Even so, treat
|
||||||
presenting it in the language of research — locating and verifying
|
"synthesized from imagery" with some caution: current LLM tooling makes
|
||||||
images is a materially harder task than an LLM can reliably do without
|
it more likely the model synthesized primarily from textual search
|
||||||
a real, working search/browsing tool. Treat the Appendix precedents as
|
results and descriptions of buildings than from genuine visual analysis
|
||||||
indicative, not verified, unless the model you're using actually has
|
of downloaded images, whatever the prompt literally asked for. Treat the
|
||||||
that capability and you've confirmed it used it.
|
Appendix precedents as text-grounded rather than confirmed
|
||||||
|
image-grounded, unless you've specifically verified that the model/tool
|
||||||
|
you're using performs real visual analysis of retrieved images and not
|
||||||
|
just text search.
|
||||||
- This document is a formal/tectonic vocabulary for description and
|
- This document is a formal/tectonic vocabulary for description and
|
||||||
illustration, not a construction specification: literal historical
|
illustration, not a construction specification: literal historical
|
||||||
materials it names (rammed earth, adobe, stone vaulting) are
|
materials it names (rammed earth, adobe, stone vaulting) are
|
||||||
|
|
|
||||||
|
|
@ -178,7 +178,9 @@ required both.
|
||||||
For this project, Salingaros produced a project-specific form-language
|
For this project, Salingaros produced a project-specific form-language
|
||||||
grammar, the *Ecuadorian Form Language Grammar*, developed after
|
grammar, the *Ecuadorian Form Language Grammar*, developed after
|
||||||
discussion with a Quito-based designer and self-builder and synthesized
|
discussion with a Quito-based designer and self-builder and synthesized
|
||||||
by an LLM from open-source reference imagery. Rather than a set of
|
by an LLM, using real web search, from open-source reference material —
|
||||||
|
though see §3.3 for a caveat on how much of that synthesis was likely
|
||||||
|
text-mediated rather than genuine visual analysis of imagery. Rather than a set of
|
||||||
historical facades to imitate, it is written as a *generative* vocabulary:
|
historical facades to imitate, it is written as a *generative* vocabulary:
|
||||||
a stratified tectonic sequence from dark Ecuadorian andesite at the
|
a stratified tectonic sequence from dark Ecuadorian andesite at the
|
||||||
plinth, through thick limewashed tapial and adobe at the lower and middle
|
plinth, through thick limewashed tapial and adobe at the lower and middle
|
||||||
|
|
@ -218,12 +220,18 @@ To check that this generalized, rather than merely described, we ran the
|
||||||
template a second time on a project unrelated to Ecuador: *Harbor House*,
|
template a second time on a project unrelated to Ecuador: *Harbor House*,
|
||||||
a travellers' inn intended to relieve pressure on homeless services, sited
|
a travellers' inn intended to relieve pressure on homeless services, sited
|
||||||
in Sheffield, South Yorkshire — a different typology, region, and
|
in Sheffield, South Yorkshire — a different typology, region, and
|
||||||
climate, produced by the paper's first author. This second run also used
|
climate, produced by the paper's first author. This second run used an
|
||||||
an LLM configuration with real web search available, so climate figures
|
LLM configuration with real web search available, so climate figures and
|
||||||
and precedent references were checked against live sources and cited
|
precedent references were checked against live sources and cited inline
|
||||||
inline rather than drawn purely from training-data recollection,
|
rather than drawn purely from training-data recollection — a condition
|
||||||
demonstrating the template is compatible with a stricter, source-checked
|
Salingaros has confirmed the original Ecuador run shared, not a stricter
|
||||||
mode of use as well as the original's. The resulting document
|
mode unique to this validation run. Even with real search available in
|
||||||
|
both cases, current LLM tool capability makes it more likely that both
|
||||||
|
runs synthesized the form language primarily from textual search results
|
||||||
|
and descriptions of buildings than from genuine visual analysis of
|
||||||
|
downloaded images, notwithstanding the original prompt's explicit request
|
||||||
|
to work from open-source imagery (§3.2) — a caveat that applies equally
|
||||||
|
to both runs, not a point of difference between them. The resulting document
|
||||||
(`projects/harbor-house/docs/sheffield.md`) follows the same section shape as the
|
(`projects/harbor-house/docs/sheffield.md`) follows the same section shape as the
|
||||||
Ecuadorian grammar while producing an entirely different vocabulary — dark
|
Ecuadorian grammar while producing an entirely different vocabulary — dark
|
||||||
gritstone and coursed rubble rather than andesite, slate and Yorkshire
|
gritstone and coursed rubble rather than andesite, slate and Yorkshire
|
||||||
|
|
|
||||||
Loading…
Add table
Reference in a new issue