homemaker-layout/tests/test_dom_corpus.py
Claude 47079997cf
The native-vs-Perl parity tests have never run, and were self-comparing
The 39.19 objective change broke three tests. They were the right ones to
break, and how they broke matters more than the change.

test_native_fitness_score_parity and test_native_fitness_fail_set_parity read a
cached .score/.fails beside each corpus .dom and assert the native Python
fitness agrees. They are the ONLY check that the native evaluator still agrees
with the Urb oracle it was ported from, and CLAUDE.md still describes oracle.py
and the Perl tool as kept for cross-validation.

But .gitignore lines 10-11 exclude *.dom.score and *.dom.fails, and
git log --diff-filter=A over those patterns finds zero files ever added on any
branch. No oracle cache has ever existed here, so on a clean checkout all 64
parametrised cases skip.

Worse than skipping is what happens when they do not. Nothing in a .score file
records who wrote it, so a .dom left in that directory by a search run -- with
a .score written by homemaker-fitness, the NATIVE scorer -- silently becomes a
parity fixture, and the test compares the native scorer with itself. That
passes by construction whatever the native scorer says.

Three such cases were live and green: the coldstart-500000-s*.dom artefacts
committed to examples/programme-house during 39.12 and scored natively this
session. They surfaced only because 39.19 made the native scorer disagree with
its own stale output; absent an objective change, a green "native matches
oracle" would have been reported indefinitely.

Stopgap: parametrisation restricted to the Perl corpus's MD5-named files so a
session artefact cannot become a fixture again; the skip message now says
parity is UNVERIFIED rather than reading like an optional missing cache; a
guard test asserts the restriction. All 64 cases skip honestly. Regenerating
the caches with the native scorer would not have been a fix -- it would have
re-cemented the self-comparison.

Filed as homemaker-py-118 (P1): regenerate fixtures from the Perl oracle,
narrow the ignore rules so fixture caches can be tracked, and find out whether
parity still holds -- it may not, since 39.14, 39.18 and 39.19 all changed the
native objective and the oracle has none of them. If parity is being abandoned
deliberately the tests should be deleted with a note. What must not survive is
a test that looks like a guarantee and is not one.

415 passed, 64 skipped.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MJ84Feep79Hhm3E4zZJmnB
2026-09-05 19:25:18 +00:00

196 lines
8 KiB
Python

"""Corpus-backed tests for dom round-trip, free-branch ownership, and fitness parity.
Skipped when the Urb checkout is absent (these need only its .dom files, not
perl). The parity tests compare native Python fitness against cached oracle
scores and failure sets (generated with URB_NO_OCCLUSION=1).
"""
import math
import re
from pathlib import Path
import pytest
from homemaker_layout import dom, solver
CORPUS = Path(__file__).parent.parent / "examples" / "programme-house"
# The parity fixtures are the Perl corpus, whose files Urb names by MD5. Any
# other .dom in this directory is something a later session generated -- a
# search artefact, a candidate, a seed -- and must NEVER be used as a parity
# fixture: its .score, if one exists, was written by the NATIVE scorer, so
# comparing against it compares the native scorer with itself and passes
# whatever the native scorer says. That is exactly what was happening here
# until 39.20; see `homemaker-py-*` for restoring real oracle fixtures.
_ORACLE_NAME = re.compile(r"^[0-9a-f]{32}\.dom$")
ORACLE_FIXTURES = sorted(p for p in CORPUS.glob("*.dom")
if _ORACLE_NAME.match(p.name))
pytestmark = pytest.mark.skipif(not CORPUS.is_dir(), reason="Corpus not available")
def test_roundtrip_idempotent_and_area_preserving(tmp_path):
# dump() does not reproduce the source bytes (different YAML style); the
# real invariants are that a dumped file reloads to the same dump (stable
# fixed point) and that per-leaf geometry survives the trip (§4.1 is the
# area validation against Urb itself).
from homemaker_layout import geometry
for src in sorted(CORPUS.glob("*.dom")):
root = dom.load(str(src))
areas = [geometry.area(leaf) for lvl in dom.levels(root) for leaf in lvl.leaves()]
once = tmp_path / ("once_" + src.name)
dom.dump(root, str(once))
root2 = dom.load(str(once))
areas2 = [geometry.area(leaf) for lvl in dom.levels(root2) for leaf in lvl.leaves()]
assert areas == pytest.approx(areas2, abs=1e-9), src.name
twice = tmp_path / ("twice_" + src.name)
dom.dump(root2, str(twice))
assert twice.read_bytes() == once.read_bytes(), src.name
def test_free_branches_known_dof():
# DOF figures from DESIGN.md §4.5
expected = {
"2f45907abd9accac2a124d311732f749.dom": 7,
"candidate-002.dom": 6,
"c964435454c459f86c3ed9a5a7621132.dom": 6,
}
for name, dof in expected.items():
root = dom.load(str(CORPUS / name))
assert len(solver.free_branches(root)) == dof, name
def test_free_branches_are_lowest_storey_owners():
for src in sorted(CORPUS.glob("*.dom")):
root = dom.load(str(src))
for b in solver.free_branches(root):
assert b.divided
assert b.below is None or not b.below.divided
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Phase 3 gate: native fitness parity vs oracle (homemaker-py-uxz)
# Oracle scores and failure sets cached as <file>.dom.score / <file>.dom.fails
# generated with URB_NO_OCCLUSION=1 (DESIGN.md §6 descope).
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
def _native_evaluate(src: Path):
"""Run native Fitness.evaluate and return (score, frozenset[fail_lines])."""
from homemaker_layout import fitness as fit_mod, graph as graph_mod, geometry
root = dom.load(str(src))
conf, cost = fit_mod.load_config(CORPUS)
fit = fit_mod.Fitness(conf, cost)
failures: list[str] = []
tracking: dict = {
"has_public_access_outside": False,
"has_public_access_inside": False,
"public_length_all": 0.0,
"public_length_outside": 0.0,
"private_length_all": 0.0,
"private_length_outside": 0.0,
"stair_fit": [],
"_failures": failures,
}
programme = fit._programme or {}
geometry.clear_cache()
check_f, missing = graph_mod.check_space_counts(root, programme)
failures.extend(check_f)
fit.preprocess_building(root)
_, gcpre = graph_mod.build_graphs_with_circ(root, fit.conf("door_width") or 1.2, failures.append, fit.usages())
gbpre = graph_mod.build_graphs(root, fit.conf("door_width") or 1.2)
failures.extend(graph_mod.check_adjacency(root, programme, gbpre, missing))
failures.extend(graph_mod.check_level_constraints(root, programme, missing))
failures.extend(graph_mod.check_vertical_connectivity(root, programme, missing))
dom.merge_divided(root)
geometry.clear_cache()
_, gc = graph_mod.build_graphs_with_circ(root, fit.conf("door_width") or 1.2, failures.append, fit.usages())
gb = graph_mod.build_graphs(root, fit.conf("door_width") or 1.2)
cost_v = fit.plot_cost(root)
value = 0.0
lvls = dom.levels(root)
for li, lvl in enumerate(lvls):
se = fit.process_storey(
lvl, gb[li], li, failures.append,
graph_circ=gc, tracking=tracking, lvls=lvls, root=root,
)
cost_v += se.cost
value += se.value
bf = fit.evaluate_building(root, tracking)
value *= bf
value *= 0.5 ** len(failures)
score = value / cost_v if cost_v else 0.0
return score, frozenset(failures)
def _oracle_result(src: Path):
"""Read cached oracle score and failure set (URB_NO_OCCLUSION=1)."""
from homemaker_layout.oracle import Score
score_file = Path(str(src) + ".score")
fails_file = Path(str(src) + ".fails")
if not score_file.exists():
pytest.skip(
f"No oracle score committed for {src.name}. `.gitignore` excludes "
"*.dom.score and *.dom.fails, and none has ever been tracked, so "
"native-vs-Perl parity is UNVERIFIED in this repository -- these "
"cases have always skipped on a clean checkout (DESIGN.md §39.20). "
"Regenerating them with the native scorer would not fix it; the "
"cache has to come from the Perl oracle.")
oracle_score = float(score_file.read_text().strip())
oracle_fails = Score(
fitness=oracle_score,
fails=fails_file.read_text() if fails_file.exists() else "",
).fail_lines
return oracle_score, frozenset(oracle_fails)
@pytest.mark.parametrize("src", ORACLE_FIXTURES, ids=lambda p: p.name)
def test_native_fitness_score_parity(src):
"""Native score matches oracle within 1e-4 relative tolerance."""
native_score, _ = _native_evaluate(src)
oracle_score, _ = _oracle_result(src)
assert math.isclose(native_score, oracle_score, rel_tol=1e-4, abs_tol=1e-15), (
f"{src.name}: native={native_score:.6e} oracle={oracle_score:.6e}"
)
@pytest.mark.parametrize("src", ORACLE_FIXTURES, ids=lambda p: p.name)
def test_native_fitness_fail_set_parity(src):
"""Native failure set matches oracle failure set exactly."""
_, native_fails = _native_evaluate(src)
_, oracle_fails = _oracle_result(src)
only_native = native_fails - oracle_fails
only_oracle = oracle_fails - native_fails
assert not only_native and not only_oracle, (
f"{src.name}: only_native={sorted(only_native)} only_oracle={sorted(only_oracle)}"
)
def test_parity_fixtures_are_never_session_artefacts():
"""Guard for the defect §39.20 records.
The parity tests read a cached `.score` beside each `.dom` and treat it as
the Perl oracle's answer. Nothing in the file says who wrote it, so a `.dom`
left behind by a search run -- with a `.score` written by the NATIVE scorer
-- silently becomes a "parity" case that compares the native scorer with
itself. Three such cases were live and passing until the §39.19 objective
change made the native scorer disagree with its own stale output.
"""
for src in ORACLE_FIXTURES:
assert _ORACLE_NAME.match(src.name), src.name
stray = [p.name for p in CORPUS.glob("*.dom")
if not _ORACLE_NAME.match(p.name)
and Path(str(p) + ".score").exists()]
assert not set(stray) & {p.name for p in ORACLE_FIXTURES}, (
f"session artefacts leaked into the parity fixtures: {stray}")