39.16 relocated the crinkliness residual to a plan-form question. Four
measurements answer it, and two of them refute the premises 773 was filed on.
The search DOES build courtyards -- harbor 8 (273 m2), maple 16 (404 m2),
health-centre 13 (107 m2) over three seeds -- and they work: of 524 lit edges
44% come from the plot wall, 30% from a courtyard, 26% from a perimeter void,
and a courtyard supplies at least one side for 53% of the two-aspect leaves.
No operator is missing. (The shape-curve DP does NOT model exposure --
shapecurve.py:25 -- but per 38.24 it fires ~8 times in 500k evals, so that gap
is not what is costing anything.)
The answer is per-storey. Comparing each storey's demand, sum A_i/(1.6202*h),
with the lit wall its leaves actually hold: every harbor and maple ground floor
is below 1.0 and every top floor above 1.2, and the ratio predicts the fail
rate almost exactly -- above ~1.2 near-zero fails, below 1.0 40-55% of the
storey. health-centre and programme-house sit at 1.6-4.2 throughout and fail
essentially nothing.
That corrects 39.11, which divided demand evenly across storeys and concluded
harbor and maple were frontage-feasible "with room to spare". Programmes pin
rooms to level 0 and the ground floor cannot set itself back to buy perimeter:
harbor's pinned 347 m2 needs 71.4 m against the plot's 53.0 m, maple's 414 m2
needs 85.2 m against 55.0 m, while health-centre and programme-house have 51.0
and 14.2 m spare. Same ordering as the corpus fail counts, and fixed before any
search runs. The averaged check is not just weaker: on maple it asks for a
22 m2 courtyard where the ground floor needs 57 m2.
New third _preflight check, advisory like the others, silent on the two
programmes with slack. tests/test_evolve_preflight.py covers all three checks
and asserts the ground-floor figure exceeds the averaged one -- if they ever
agree, one has stopped earning its place. 39.11 annotated in place.
Also recorded, not acted on: the open space is on the wrong storey (harbor puts
50 m2 of courtyard on the starved ground floor and 223 m2 on the surplus first
floor), because value_rate pays an outside leaf above ground value_supported =
300 -- a room's rate -- against a cost of 110, with nothing tying its value to
whether it illuminates anything. Filed as homemaker-py-ecx.
411 passed, 72 skipped.
Refs homemaker-py-773.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01MJ84Feep79Hhm3E4zZJmnB
f5612ce06c