Strategy decision (Bruno): occlusion is orthogonal to building a scalable
optimiser. Instead of porting Sun/Occlusion/CIESky, disable it in Urb
behind an env flag (daylight -> 1, illumination factor -> 1 so crinkliness
is unweighted external wall area / floor area). Python occlusion rebuild
deferred until optimisation is fully native.
Tracker: new homemaker-py-gp2 (flag + re-baseline) gates gnw/way/uxz;
homemaker-py-2g5 re-scoped to the post-Phase-5 Python rebuild (P4).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
oracle.score_batch() writes/cleans N outputs and runs urb-fitness.pl once
with all file names; oracle.score() is now a thin wrapper. Adds
Score.fail_lines (sorted) because Perl hash-order randomisation shuffles
.fails line order between runs, and documents Urb's ~1-ULP score
nondeterminism (compare with rel tolerance, never ==).
experiments/bench_batch_oracle.py validates batch-vs-single parity on the
35-file corpus and benchmarks: 0.98 s/dom batched vs 1.27 s/dom single
(x1.30), all files identical (fitness to 1e-12 rel, exact failure sets).
Closes homemaker-py-av5.
Self-contained design + plan structured for breaking into bd (beads) tasks:
domain constraints that fix the slicing representation; what was built;
full empirical record (geometry port validated 35/35; area-proxy solver
falsified; perpendicular artifact resolved via equal-offset cuts; full-fitness
frozen-topology optimisation validated with 24-67% headroom; 0.5^n cliff);
validated memetic architecture; component plan; phased roadmap; risks/open
questions; repro steps; gotchas.
Oracle throughput measured: ~0.99s/dom batched vs 1.65s single (assessment-
dominated). urb-fitness.pl batches many doms per call, so native fitness is a
later speed/scale optimisation, not a gate; favour population/batch optimisers
and prototype the search on the batched oracle first.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Driving equal-offset cut ratios with Nelder-Mead against the REAL oracle
fitness (full objective, no proxy) improves all three test candidates with
zero new failures:
2f45907 (best evolved) 0.012617 -> 0.015684 x1.24 (2->2 fails)
candidate-002 0.007375 -> 0.012319 x1.67 (2->2 fails)
c964435 (baseline) 0.003667 -> 0.005836 x1.59 (3->3 fails)
Headroom widens on weaker designs. The EA under-optimises geometry by
24-67% even on its best result. This validates a full-fitness geometry
inner loop (NOT the earlier area-proxy solver) and motivates a memetic
architecture: topology search outside, full-objective geometry optimise
inside, gated on a native Python fitness (oracle at ~3s/call is too slow).
Adds the bottom-up ratio solver, programme parser, Perl-oracle bridge,
and two experiments. Headline finding: the "isolated size solver on a
frozen topology" hypothesis is NOT validated.
- resolve_ratios.py: re-solving candidate-002 from programme targets
recovers areas accurately but scores below the original (introduces
width/perpendicular/crinkliness failures the area objective ignores).
- refine_sweep.py: warm-start refine of all 34 evolved candidates
regresses 34/34 (fails 124->297 perpendicular-tied; 124->626 area-only
with free skew). Moving cuts to fix room area breaks the coupled
adjacency/access/shape constraints those designs balanced.
Conclusion: sizing is not separable from the rest of Urb's fitness;
a geometry inner loop must optimise the full objective, not an area proxy.
Geometry port remains validated byte-identical to Urb.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Clean-room Python successor to Urb for programme-driven layout search.
This initial commit establishes the .dom bridge format and a faithful
port of Urb's top-down quad geometry, validated byte-identical against
Urb across all 35 programme-house example files (including the wall
inset and multi-storey wall-stacking inheritance).
- dom.py: .dom YAML <-> Node tree, parent/below/position linkage,
wall_outer inset on load, raw-corner stash for round-tripping
- geometry.py: Coordinate/Coordinate_a/_b/Area/Length + Coordinate_Offset
- experiments/dump_areas.{py,pl}: geometry regression harness
